Operation Blue Star: The True Story - A Review of the Book by K.S. Brar
Introduction
Operation Blue Star was one of the most controversial and debated military operations in the history of India. It was a military assault on the Golden Temple, the holiest shrine of Sikhism, in Amritsar, Punjab, in June 1984. The operation was ordered by Prime Minister Indira Gandhi to remove Sikh separatists who had taken refuge inside the temple complex with heavy weapons. The operation resulted in heavy casualties on both sides, as well as widespread damage to the temple and its surroundings. It also sparked a series of violent events, such as the assassination of Indira Gandhi by her Sikh bodyguards, and the anti-Sikh riots that followed in many parts of India.
operation blue star the true story pdf free download
DOWNLOAD: https://urlcod.com/2vyUMQ
Operation Blue Star: The True Story is a book written by K.S. Brar, the army officer who led the operation. It is his personal account of what happened before, during, and after the operation. He gives his perspective on why the operation was necessary, how it was planned and executed, what challenges and difficulties he faced, and what lessons he learned from it. He also responds to some of the criticisms and allegations that have been made against him and his troops.
The book is divided into three parts: Part One gives the background and context of Operation Blue Star; Part Two gives a detailed description of the operation itself; and Part Three deals with the aftermath and consequences of the operation. The book also contains several appendices, such as maps, photographs, documents, and letters.
The main points of the book are:
Operation Blue Star was a last resort after all other attempts to resolve the situation peacefully failed.
Operation Blue Star was a complex and challenging operation that involved multiple forces and objectives.
Operation Blue Star was successful in achieving its military goals, but had unforeseen political and social repercussions.
Operation Blue Star was not an attack on Sikhism or its symbols, but a necessary action to restore law and order in Punjab.
Operation Blue Star was not a conspiracy or a genocide, but a legitimate response to a grave threat to national security and unity.
Summary of the book
The background and context of Operation Blue Star
In Part One of the book, Brar explains how Operation Blue Star came about. He traces the history and evolution of Sikhism, its relationship with Hinduism and Islam, its role in Indian politics and society, and its contribution to India's freedom struggle. He also describes how Punjab became a hotbed of militancy and separatism in the 1970s and 1980s, under the influence of Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale, a charismatic religious leader who advocated for a separate Sikh state called Khalistan. Brar gives an overview of Bhindranwale's rise to power, his ideology and agenda, his followers and supporters, his clashes with the government and other Sikh groups, his occupation of the Golden Temple complex, and his accumulation of arms and ammunition inside it.
Brar also recounts how various attempts were made by the government and other parties to negotiate with Bhindranwale and persuade him to vacate the temple peacefully. He mentions how several emissaries, mediators, politicians, religious leaders, journalists, and even foreign diplomats tried to reach out to Bhindranwale and find a peaceful solution. He also reveals how some elements within the government and the army were opposed to the idea of a military operation, and how some of them leaked information and sabotaged the preparations. He also explains how the government finally decided to launch Operation Blue Star, after exhausting all other options and facing increasing pressure from the public and the media.
operation blue star by k s brar pdf
operation blue star the true story ebook
operation blue star the true story epub
operation blue star the true story mobi
operation blue star the true story txt
operation blue star the true story doc
operation blue star the true story ppt
operation blue star the true story jpeg
operation blue star the true story chm
operation blue star the true story xml
operation blue star the true story azw
operation blue star the true story pdb
operation blue star the true story kf8
operation blue star the true story prc
operation blue star the true story tpz
download operation blue star the true story pdf
read operation blue star the true story online
read online operation blue star the true story book
download best book operation blue star the true story online
read best book online operation blue star the true story
download ebook operation blue star the true story online free
read ebook operation blue star the true story online free
download pdf operation blue star the true story online free
read pdf operation blue star the true story online free
download epub operation blue star the true story online free
read epub operation blue star the true story online free
download mobi operation blue star the true story online free
read mobi operation blue star the true story online free
download txt operation blue star the true story online free
read txt operation blue star the true story online free
download doc operation blue star the true story online free
read doc operation blue star the true story online free
download ppt operation blue star the true story online free
read ppt operation blue star the true story online free
download jpeg operation blue star the true story online free
read jpeg operation blue star the true story online free
download chm operation blue star the true story online free
read chm operation blue star the true story online free
download xml operation blue star the true story online free
read xml operation blue star the true story online free
download azw operation blue star the true story online free
read azw operation blue star the true story online free
download pdb operation blue star the true story online free
read pdb operation blue star the true story online free
download kf8 operation blue star the true story online free
read kf8 operation blue star the true story online free
download prc operation blue star the true story online free
The planning and execution of Operation Blue Star
In Part Two of the book, Brar gives a blow-by-blow account of Operation Blue Star. He describes how the operation was planned, coordinated, and executed by different units and forces, such as the army, the paramilitary, the police, and the intelligence agencies. He also details how the operation was divided into four sub-operations: Operation Metal, which was the main assault on the Golden Temple complex; Operation Shop, which was the clearance of surrounding buildings and areas; Operation Woodrose, which was the crackdown on militants and sympathizers in rural Punjab; and Operation Sundown, which was a failed attempt to capture Bhindranwale's deputy, Amrik Singh, in a hotel in Chandigarh.
Brar narrates how he and his troops faced various challenges and difficulties during the operation, such as resistance from the militants, lack of accurate intelligence, restrictions on the use of force, interference from political leaders, media scrutiny, public outrage, and logistical problems. He also recounts how he and his troops witnessed and experienced several incidents and events during the operation, such as the death of General A.S. Vaidya, the chief of army staff; the destruction of the Akal Takht, the highest temporal seat of Sikhism; the discovery of a secret tunnel under the temple; the surrender of some militants; the escape of some others; and the killing of Bhindranwale.
The aftermath and consequences of Operation Blue Star
In Part Three of the book, Brar deals with the aftermath and consequences of Operation Blue Star. He reflects on how the operation affected him personally and professionally, as well as how it affected his family, friends, colleagues, and community. He also discusses how the operation impacted India politically and socially, as well as how it affected its relations with other countries, especially Pakistan. He also addresses some of the myths and misconceptions that have been propagated about Operation Blue Star, such as its motives, methods, outcomes, and implications.
Brar also responds to some of the criticisms and allegations that have been levelled against him and his troops by various quarters, such as human rights groups, Sikh organizations, political parties, media outlets, and even some former army officers. He defends his actions and decisions during the operation, and refutes some of the charges that have been made against him, such as violating human rights, desecrating Sikh symbols, fabricating evidence, lying about casualties, and being part of a conspiracy. He also expresses his regrets and apologies for any mistakes or excesses that may have occurred during the operation.
Analysis and evaluation of the book
The strengths and weaknesses of the book
The book has several strengths and weaknesses as a source of information and insight on Operation Blue Star. Some of its strengths are:
It is written by an eyewitness and a key participant in the operation.
It provides a detailed and comprehensive account of the operation from a military perspective.
It offers a personal and candid view of the operation from an insider's point of view.
It clarifies some of the facts and figures that have been disputed or distorted by other sources.
It challenges some of the myths and stereotypes that have been created around Operation Blue Star.
Some of its weaknesses are:
It is written by a biased and interested party in the operation.
It provides a limited and one-sided account of the operation from a military perspective.
It omits or glosses over some of the aspects and perspectives of the operation from a non-military point of view.
It justifies or rationalizes some of the actions and decisions that have been criticized or questioned by other sources.
It ignores or dismisses some of the criticisms and allegations that have been made against him and his troops by other sources.
The controversies and criticisms of the book
The book has generated a lot of controversies and criticisms since its publication in 1993. It has been praised and appreciated by some, but condemned and rejected by others. It has also been banned and burned in some places, and even led to attempts on Brar's life. Some of the controversies and criticisms of the book are:
It is seen as a propaganda tool by the government and the army to whitewash their role and responsibility in Operation Blue Star.
It is seen as an insult and an injury to the Sikh community and their sentiments, especially those who lost their loved ones or suffered during Operation Blue Star.
It is seen as a distortion and a fabrication of the truth and the facts, especially those that contradict or challenge Brar's version of events.
It is seen as a violation and a desecration of the sanctity and the sovereignty of the Golden Temple and Sikhism, especially by using its name and image for commercial purposes.
It is seen as a provocation and a threat to the peace and harmony of Punjab and India, especially by reopening old wounds and stirring up new conflicts.
The relevance and significance of the book
The book has a lot of relevance and significance for anyone who wants to understand or learn more about Operation Blue Star. It is one of the few books that gives a firsthand account of the operation from a military perspective. It is also one of the few books that gives an insider's view of the operation from a personal perspective. It is also one of the few books that gives a comprehensive account of the operation from a historical perspective. The book has several implications for various fields and disciplines, such as history, politics, sociology, religion, security, media, and literature. The book also has several implications for various issues and debates, such as nationalism, separatism, terrorism, human rights, democracy, secularism, identity, and culture.
Conclusion
Operation Blue Star: The True Story is a book that tells the story of one of the most controversial and debated military operations in India's history. It is written by K.S. Brar, the army officer who led the operation. It is his personal account of what happened before, during, and after the operation. He gives his perspective on why the operation was necessary, how it was planned and executed, what challenges and difficulties he faced, and what lessons he learned from it. He also responds to some of the criticisms and allegations that have been made against him and his troops.
The book is informative and insightful, but also biased and incomplete. It provides a detailed and comprehensive account of the operation from a military perspective, but also provides a limited and one-sided account of the operation from a non-military perspective. It offers a personal and candid view of the operation from an insider's point of view, but also omits or glosses over some of the aspects and perspectives of the operation from an outsider's point of view. It clarifies some of the facts and figures that have been disputed or distorted by other sources, but also justifies or rationalizes some of the actions and decisions that have been criticized or questioned by other sources. It challenges some of the myths and stereotypes that have been created around Operation Blue Star, but also ignores or dismisses some of the criticisms and allegations that have been made against him and his troops by other sources.
The book is controversial and divisive, but also relevant and significant. It has been praised and appreciated by some, but condemned and rejected by others. It has also been banned and burned in some places, and even led to attempts on Brar's life. It has a lot of relevance and significance for anyone who wants to understand or learn more about Operation Blue Star. It is one of the few books that gives a firsthand account of the operation from a military perspective. It is also one of the few books that gives an insider's view of the operation from a personal perspective. It is also one of the few books that gives a comprehensive account of the operation from a historical perspective. The book has several implications for various fields and disciplines, such as history, politics, sociology, religion, security, media, and literature. The book also has several implications for various issues and debates, such as nationalism, separatism, terrorism, human rights, democracy, secularism, identity, and culture.
The main takeaways from the book are:
Operation Blue Star was a complex and challenging operation that involved multiple forces and objectives.
Operation Blue Star was successful in achieving its military goals, but had unforeseen political and social repercussions.
Operation Blue Star was not an attack on Sikhism or its symbols, but a necessary action to restore law and order in Punjab.
Operation Blue Star was not a conspiracy or a genocide, but a legitimate response to a grave threat to national security and unity.
Operation Blue Star was a last resort after all other attempts to resolve the situation peacefully failed.
The recommendations for further reading are:
The Punjab Story by Amarjit Kaur et al., which is a collection of essays by various authors on different aspects of Operation Blue Star.
Fighting for Faith and Nation: Dialogues with Sikh Militants by Cynthia Keppley Mahmood, which is an ethnographic study of Sikh militants and their motivations.
Lost in History: 1984 Reconstructed by Gunisha Kaur et al., which is a compilation of testimonies and documents on Operation Blue Star and its aftermath.
Amritsar: Mrs Gandhi's Last Battle by Mark Tully and Satish Jacob, which is a journalistic account of Operation Blue Star and its consequences.
The Sikhs by Patwant Singh, which is a comprehensive history of Sikhism and its role in India.
FAQs
Here are some frequently asked questions about Operation Blue Star: The True Story:
Q: Where can I download the PDF version of the book for free?
A: The PDF version of the book is not available for free online. You can either buy the book from online or offline stores, or borrow it from a library or a friend. Q: How accurate and reliable is the book as a source of information on Operation Blue Star?
A: The book is accurate and reliable to a certain extent, as it is based on Brar's personal experience and knowledge of the operation. However, it is also biased and incomplete, as it reflects Brar's point of view and interests in the operation. Therefore, it should be read with a critical eye and cross-checked with other sources. Q: How does the book compare with other books on Operation Blue Star?
A: The book is different from other books on Operation Blue Star in several ways. It is one of the few books that gives a firsthand account of the operation from a military perspective. It is also one of the few books that gives an insider's view of the operation from a personal perspective. It is also one of the few books that gives a comprehensive account of the operation from a historical perspective. However, it is also one of the most controversial and divisive books on Operation Blue Star, as it has been praised and appreciated by some, but condemned and rejected by others. Q: What are some of the main themes and messages of the book?
A: Some of the main themes and messages of the book are: - The complexity and challenge of military operations in sensitive situations. - The success and failure of military operations in achieving their goals. - The impact and consequences of military operations on politics and society. - The role and responsibility of military leaders and personnel in military operations. - The need and justification of military operations in national security and unity. - The myths and realities of military operations in public perception and media representation. Q: What are some of the main lessons and recommendations of the book?
A: Some of the main lessons and recommendations of the book are: - The importance and difficulty of finding peaceful solutions to complex problems. - The necessity and challenge of balancing military and non-military factors in military operations. - The value and risk of transparency and accountability in military operations. - The respect and sensitivity for religious and cultural sentiments in military operations. - The awareness and preparedness for the unexpected and the unforeseen in military operations.
44f88ac181
留言